More Asia - TOP ASIA STORIES - Horrific gang-rape changing India

CNN speaks exclusively with the parents of a women gang raped on a bus in India and finds a country changing as a result of the crime that shocked the world. FULL STORY | COVERING THE RAPE
CNN speaks exclusively with the parents of a women gang raped on a bus in India and finds a country changing as a result of the crime that shocked the world. FULL STORY

 

'Nirbhaya,' victim of India gang rape fought for justice

By Samantha Bresnahan, Sumnima Udas, and Ram Ramgopal, CNN
December 4, 2013 -- Updated 2259 GMT (0659 HKT)
Watch this video

'Nirbhaya' parents and doctors speak out

STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • It has been one year since December 16 gang rape in India
  • "Nirbhaya" was 23-year-old medical student taking a break before her internship
  • Her attack struck a nerve and galvanized a nation
  • "I am hopeful," her mother says that it "help change the way people think"
Editor's note: Nearly one year after the gang rape and murder of a 23-year-old woman in India, CNN's World's Untold Stories takes a look at the events of this defining case in India's history through the eyes of those most closely involved -- the girl's parents, the chief police investigator, and one of her doctors. For the first time, hear exclusive details about what happened behind closed doors in the hospital and the courtroom. First screening on Saturday, December 7 at 9.30 a.m. ET. (2.30 p.m. GMT)
(CNN) -- The colorful, busy streets of New Delhi, India's capital, are a mixture of old and new. Some people have modern attitudes, while others remain rooted in ancient values.
A 23-year-old female medical student from Ballia, in India's Uttar Pradesh State, had set out to change that. She had plans to give free medical care to the needy, to provide for her family, and to change those perceptions that a woman can't dream big in a traditionally male-dominated society.
She was the bridge between India, old and new.
But what happened to her on December 16, 2012 would be the country's tipping point -- a rape that shook the nation.
In India, there are laws for the protection of rape victims. These laws prohibit naming or showing a victim, which is why we will refer to her only as "Nirbhaya," one of the many names given to her by the public and the Indian media.
In Hindi, it means "the fearless one."
A family's 'pillar of strength'
In an apartment provided by the government, the young woman's mother, Asha Devi, said her daughter had dreams of providing free medical care to those who could not afford it. She also said her daughter was a "pillar of strength to the family," which includes two brothers.
Nirbhaya's father, Badrinath Singh, a baggage handler at the Delhi airport, earned barely enough to make ends meet. He also shared his daughter's dream.
Her father, Badrinath Singh cuts vegetables at his home in India.
Her father, Badrinath Singh cuts vegetables at his home in India.
"We did everything we could for her education," he told us. "I worked double shifts, sold our only piece of land in the village and went beyond my capacity so that she could study. Doing a 16-hour shift at my age is very difficult, but I still did it."
Last December, Nirbhaya was scheduled to start an internship. Her parents wanted her to have some fun. She thought of going to a movie. Her mother agreed -- otherwise, she would not have had a chance to relax for another few months.
So Nirbhaya and a male friend set out to an upscale Delhi mall to watch Ang Lee's "Life of Pi."
That night was December 16, 2012. The next time Singh and Devi would see their daughter, she'd be fighting for her life.
A bus ride from hell
When Nirbhaya and her friend finished the movie, they tried to find an auto rickshaw, a three-wheeled taxi, to take them back to the outskirts of the city. It was a 45-minute drive no one was willing to take that night. Instead, they boarded a white bus at a busy bus stop.
It was not late at night. She was not out alone. They were taking public transportation. She had done all the things women all over the world are told to do in the interest of safety.
It was not enough.
On the bus were five other male passengers and a male driver. At first, nothing seemed out of the ordinary. But shortly after they boarded the bus, her male friend was beaten, and the young woman was dragged to the back of the bus and violently gang raped. The men took turns, even violating her with an iron rod. They beat them both within an inch of their lives, as the bus drove around Delhi for over an hour.
Policemen inspect an impounded bus, suspected to be the vehicle where five men and a youth gang-raped a student while driving around the city.
Policemen inspect an impounded bus, suspected to be the vehicle where five men and a youth gang-raped a student while driving around the city.
Then, the men dumped them on the side of the road, left for dead.
No one would help them, until a few police cars showed up. According to the male friend, the policemen weren't sure who had jurisdiction. They waited for an ambulance that never came, he said. So he carried his bleeding friend to a police van, and they took her to Safdarjung Hospital.
"The atrocious, unbelievable injuries that she had sustained, we had never seen before," said Dr. MC Mishra, one of the many doctors who would treat her in the coming days. "In my almost 40 years of career, I have never witnessed such a horrific brutality by human beings."
'I will get better soon'
Her mother waiting at home sensed something was awry.
"That day she didn't call back after leaving home," she said. "Usually she would call us and inform as soon as she'd reach the place. It was half past eight and we hadn't heard from her. We tried calling her but she didn't answer the phone."
Nirbhaya's mother, Asha Devi mourns her daughter.
Nirbhaya's mother, Asha Devi mourns her daughter.
They waited and called again.
"It seemed as if she dropped her phone while trying to answer and the line got disconnected," her mother said.
Family of rape victim shares their story
The girl whose rape changed a country
India gang rape: Four sentenced to death
Anger over lighter sentence for juvenile
An assault on humanity in India
They called again, but this time her daughter's cell phone was switched off.
When the phone finally rang, it was not their daughter on the other end. It was someone at Safdarjung Hospital, telling them their daughter was in surgery.
When they found their daughter there, they were speechless.
"What was in front of our eyes what hard to even imagine," Devi, her mother said. "We didn't know how to react for the first few moments."
Their daughter lay on a stretcher, but she was conscious.
"She looked at me and started crying," her dad recalled.
He tried to soothe his only daughter. Keep calm, and do not worry anymore, he told her. He would take care of everything, he assured her.
"I couldn't be with her for long," he said. "I just couldn't see her in so much pain. I would keep visiting her every few hours but wouldn't stay longer. I'd go and pat on her head. At times she'd be sleeping. She would smile whenever she saw me. But I didn't have the courage to see her like that."
Nirbhaya told her mother they beat her badly.
"What could she say... even I didn't have the courage to ask her anything," Devi said. "She was in great pain, so we never asked her anything."
Even in so much pain, Nirbhaya tried to reassure her parents.
She kept telling them: "Don't worry, I'm doing better and will get better very soon."
Rape that shocked the world
Unfortunately, what happened to Nirbhaya is not uncommon in India. The country, with a combination of conservative, male-dominated thinking and weak law enforcement, has recently been in the spotlight for widespread violence against women. But it is not a new problem.
In 2012, there were 706 reported rapes in Delhi alone. Nationwide, a woman is raped every 20 minutes. But those numbers don't tell the whole story. Most rapes are never reported -- and never prosecuted -- mainly to avoid the stigma of damaged honor in a country where victims of sexual assault are often viewed with suspicion.
But it was what happened next that made this case different.
Within days, word had spread across India and around the world. The brutal nature of the attack had struck a nerve. And in their thousands, Indian citizens -- both men and women -- took to the streets in protest. Enough was enough, they shouted. It is time to protect women in India.
In the hospital, Nirbhaya and her parents weren't aware of what was happening until a doctor showed them a newscast. They saw the protesters. They also saw the police trying to keep them at bay with water cannons.
Police unleash water cannon and fire tear gas towards in Delhi on December 22, 2012.
Police unleash water cannon and fire tear gas towards in Delhi on December 22, 2012.
"That day I felt whatever was happening wasn't right," said Nirbhaya's father. "Our daughter's life was already at stake. If these protests took anymore lives, it would have been worse. It was winter and water cannons would have caused much harm. At that time, through media, I appealed to the public to maintain calm.
"We never thought something like this could ever happen to us," said her mother. "It shook the entire nation and led to public outrage on the streets. After seeing all that, we felt humanity still prevails on this earth."
A fight to the end
Meanwhile, lead police investigator Chhaya Sharma and her team worked tirelessly to find the rapists. In the hospital, Sharma said, Nirbhaya was crucial in providing clues to the police.
Lead police investigator Chhaya Sharma said Nirbhaya provided crucial clues in solving the case.
Lead police investigator Chhaya Sharma said Nirbhaya provided crucial clues in solving the case.
She and the male friend helped lead investigators to the white bus, and to its driver -- Ram Singh -- who had driven the bus around as the gang rape took place. He eventually led them to the other five men who had been on board that night. By December 22, according to Sharma, all six suspects had been arrested.
But back in the hospital, Nirbhaya was slowly losing her fight. The vicious attack had damaged her intestines, which had to be removed. The decision was made to transfer her to a hospital in Singapore. But she developed an infection, and later died there on December 29, 2012.
"Her brothers, father and I had gone with her to Singapore," said Nirbhaya's mother. "All four of us were standing right next to her when she took her last breath. What could we do? We quietly kept on gazing at her from one corner, crying. Being in a foreign land we didn't know anybody, we couldn't even understand their language so we had no idea what the doctors were saying among themselves."
Hospital staff carry the Indian gang-rape victim's body to the police morgue vehicle at Singapore's Mount Elizabeth Hospital.
Hospital staff carry the Indian gang-rape victim's body to the police morgue vehicle at Singapore's Mount Elizabeth Hospital.
Then doctors came to them. "Sorry, there's nothing we can do now."
"That's when we realized our daughter was no more," her mother said.
With heavy hearts, Nirbhaya's family returned to India at the end of 2012 with their daughter's body. When the news spread that she had died, anger turned to grief, and protests became vigils.
"To tell you the truth, I saw on TV what was happening outside, but could not register anything, as our minds were preoccupied by something else," said Nirbhaya's father.
"We understood the magnitude of the impact of this incident only once I reached my native village with my daughter's ashes. That's when I figured it wasn't ordinary. People kept coming and sharing with us all that had happened in past few days. So after listening to all those stories, I realized we are not alone, we have full support of our fellow citizens, media and police in our fight for justice."
The reckoning
That fight for justice would be a long and complicated road. The charges against the accused were rape, kidnapping and murder. With the public in the streets once again, the prosecution decided it would fast-track the trial.
In the courtroom, Nirbhaya's parents came face-to-face with her alleged attackers. They were forced to hear accounts of the unspeakable violence against their daughter, time and time again.
"The convicts showed no remorse," said Nirbhaya's mother. "They were not even ashamed of what they had done. They were very casual, sometimes even cracking jokes during the trial."
Nirbhaya's mother and brother walk through a media swarm.
Nirbhaya's mother and brother walk through a media swarm.
"It didn't really affect me looking at them," said her father. "If there are demons in society then there are also angels. Because of their deeds, our family is suffering, and so must be theirs. Whatever happened has caused pain on both sides. We are suffering as we lost a loved one. Their families will suffer if they lose them. People like them don't just ruin one family but thousands of families because of their evil acts."
The trial went on for months. Then, in March 2013, the bus driver Ram Singh was found dead in his jail cell, where he had apparently hanged himself. And the sixth suspect, a minor at the time of the attack, was convicted in a juvenile court. He was sentenced to only three years in a rehabilitation center, prompting further outrage from the public and the family.
The fate of the remaining four suspects remained with the fast-tracked court.
The guilty verdict the entire country had been waiting for came in September.
In a stunning move for a country that rarely condones the death penalty, the four convicted men were indeed sentenced to die.
This shows the four convicted prisoners for the murder and gang rape of Nirbhaya. From left to right: Akshay Thakur, Vinay Sharma, Mukesh Singh and Pawan Gupta.
This shows the four convicted prisoners for the murder and gang rape of Nirbhaya. From left to right: Akshay Thakur, Vinay Sharma, Mukesh Singh and Pawan Gupta.
Ten months since the death of their daughter, Nirbhaya's parents finally felt they had justice.
"The incident sparked reactions from across the nation," said her mother. "There was so much public outrage due to the brutality involved. The convicts were also handed out punishment according to the crime they committed. So I am hopeful it should set a precedent and help change the way people think."
A brave heart
To India, Nirbhaya has become a symbol of bravery, courage and change.
But to her parents, she will always be their baby girl.
"Our grief can't be measured," her father said quietly. "Whatever maximum limit you can think of will still fall short of the pain we went through. I don't have words to describe my loss. We had lost sense of everything -- from eating to sleeping to everything else. We had lost track of day and night. Everything had come to a standstill."
Nearly a year after the attack, India is a changed country. Women -- and men -- are standing up for their rights -- the right to be protected, in their own cities and in their own homes.
Indian activists hold a candlelight vigil on December 30 after the death of Nirbhaya.
Indian activists hold a candlelight vigil on December 30 after the death of Nirbhaya.
Since the attack, police say more women are reporting crimes against them.
India's laws have also been changed to widely expand protection of sexual assault victims.
That will be the lasting legacy of Nirbhaya, a girl India has never met in person, never seen.
The girl who did not allow anyone who came in contact with her to feel sorry for her situation. The girl who reassured her parents she would be OK. The girl who helped police track down her attackers. The girl who lived for nearly two weeks, when no one gave her a chance to make it through the first night. The girl they call Nirbhaya, "the fearless one."
"My daughter put up a tough fight against her attackers and didn't give in until her last breath," said Nirbhaya's mother. "I want her to be remembered as a brave heart."

TOP ASIA STORIES

TOP EUROPE STORIES - Lee Rigby trial: 'It brings me little joy' to kill, says suspect - Lawson says she used cocaine twice Lawson says she used cocaine twice

One of the men accused of the daylight murder of British soldier Lee Rigby told police he took little joy in killing, a court hears. FULL STORY
  • Prosecutor: 'Callous murder'  Prosecutor: 'Callous murder'
     

    'It brings me little joy' to kill, suspect in British soldier Lee Rigby's slaying says

    By Kellie Morgan, CNN
    December 4, 2013 -- Updated 2147 GMT (0547 HKT)
    Watch this video

    Prosecutor outlines 'callous murder'

    STORY HIGHLIGHTS
    • Jurors hear Michael Adebolajo's police interview on the fourth day of his murder trial
    • He and Michael Adebowale have pleaded not guilty in the killing of soldier Lee Rigby in May
    • In the interview, he praised Allah and his treatment by police, criticized British rulers
    • Adebolajo polite, didn't show signs of mental disorder, regret or remorse, psychiatrist says
    London (CNN) -- One of the men accused of the brutal daylight killing of British soldier Lee Rigby told police he took little joy in slaying.
    Michael Adebolajo's interview with police was played to jurors at the Old Bailey criminal court in London on Wednesday, day four of the trial in which he and co-defendant Michael Adebowale have pleaded not guilty to the murder of Rigby in Woolwich on May 22.
    In the interview, Adebolajo identified himself as Mujahideen Abu Hamza and began a long and uninterrupted statement by praising Allah and expressing his surprise and gratitude for the way he had been treated by police and medical staff, given what he described as "the serious nature of events."
    "There still remain some great qualities in this nation," the British-born Adebolajo told police before saying he was ashamed to be called British.
    "That title -- British -- is associated with the pillaging and rape of innocent people. This disgusts me to the core."
    He went on to say that he did not enjoy watching horror movies or seeing blood spilled.
    "It brings me little joy to approach anybody and slay them. Can you believe me?"
    The jury has seen graphic mobile phone and CCTV footage of Adebolajo brandishing a machete and knife with his hands covered in blood after the attack on Rigby.
    Adebolajo told police he would answer only questions he believed would help the British people.
    "I am not here to satisfy your supervisor," he said. "I'm only here to prevent such an incident as happened on Wednesday, the 22nd of May, from ever happening again."
    He did answer one direct question from police in the interview, and it concerned what he did to Rigby.
    "Lee Rigby was killed on the 22nd of May," he said. "He was struck in the neck with a sharp implement and it was sawn until his head, you know, became almost detached, and may Allah forgive me of I acted in a way that is displeasing to him."
    Pathologist Simon Poole told the court Wednesday that drummer Rigby suffered "numerous and very deep wounds" to the neck and that the cause of death was "multiple incised wounds."
    During Adebolajo's two-hour interview with police, he also criticized British rulers whom he described as "wicked and black-hearted humans" from privileged schools like Eton, who wore expensive suits and drove expensive cars.
    He singled out Prime Minister David Cameron; brothers David and Ed Milliband, the political veterans; and Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg.
    He expressed particular disappointment with Cameron, who he said is trying to emulate a man he described as "using the magic of the tongue to dodge questions. He goes by the name of Tony Blair. Nobody realizes the wickedness and corruption of this man."
    Earlier in the day, the court heard the statement of forensic psychiatrist Tim McKinley, who interviewed Adebolajo three times while he was being treated in a hospital after being shot by police shortly after the attack on Rigby. The psychiatrist described the defendant as polite and said he showed no signs of mental disorder, remorse or regret. Adebolajo told him he posed no threat to civilians, police or medical staff but would be a continued threat to the British military.
     
    December 4, 2013 -- Updated 1620 GMT (0020 HKT)
    Celebrity chef Nigella Lawson twice used cocaine, she admitted Wednesday as she testified in the fraud trial of two former personal assistants in a London court. FULL STORY | VIDEO  Video

     

    Chef Nigella Lawson admits using cocaine, denies drug problem

    By Laura Smith-Spark and Claudia Rebaza, CNN
    December 4, 2013 -- Updated 2148 GMT (0548 HKT)
    Watch this video

    Celebrity chef on the stand

    STORY HIGHLIGHTS
    • "I did not have a drug problem, I had a life problem," says Nigella Lawson
    • Lawson admits using cocaine during two periods of her life
    • Ex-husband said he'd "destroy" her if she didn't "clear his name," Lawson tells court
    • Italian sisters Francesca and Elisabetta Grillo deny embezzling large sums
    London (CNN) -- Celebrity chef Nigella Lawson used cocaine during two periods of her life, she admitted Wednesday as she testified in the fraud trial of two former personal assistants in a London court.
    She told the court she had used the drug about six times with her late husband, John Diamond, when he learned that his cancer was terminal, in order to give him "some escape from his treatment."
    She also used cocaine once in July 2010 when she felt subject to "terrorism" by her then-husband Charles Saatchi, she said.
    At that point she felt trapped, isolated and unhappy, she said, and a friend offered her the drug.
    But, Lawson said, "I've never been a drug addict, I've never been an habitual user. ... I did not have a drug problem, I had a life problem."
    Saatchi had claimed in an e-mail that Lawson had used drugs regularly, but in testimony Friday he backed off that claim.
    Lawson's admission of cocaine use came after she earlier testified that Saatchi had threatened to "destroy" her if she did not "clear his name."
    She had been asked about her reluctance to attend court as a witness in the assistants' trial -- a case that has gripped the media as claims emerge about the couple's troubled personal life.
    "I have been put on trial here where I am called to answer, and glad to answer the allegations, and the world's press, and it comes after a long summer of bullying and abuse," Lawson said. "I find it's another chapter in that."
    Nigella Lawson's ex in court
    Drug allegations against celebrity chef
    Referring to Saatchi's request for her to attend the trial, made in a letter sent by his lawyers, Lawson said: "He had said to me if I didn't get back to him and clear his name he would destroy me."
    Lawson said she felt she had to do her civic duty. "It's difficult for me, it's very difficult for my children, but I want to do the right thing," she added.
    The former aides, Italian sisters Francesca and Elisabetta Grillo, deny embezzling hundreds of thousands of pounds on company credit cards while employed by Lawson and Saatchi.
    'No hard evidence'
    In his testimony last Friday, Saatchi addressed the claim made in an e-mail he sent to Lawson in October that alleged she had used drugs.
    He told the court he never saw his wife taking drugs during their 10-year marriage and he had no hard evidence she had done so. He also said he was "utterly heartbroken" by the end of their relationship.
    In the e-mail, which was shared with the court by the defense in a pretrial hearing, Saatchi wrote that the assistants would likely "get off" because Lawson was using cocaine and marijuana on a daily basis and "allowed the sisters to spend whatever they liked."
    The allegations emerged in June, around the time the couple were photographed in a restaurant having an argument.
    In the photos, which were splashed across the front pages of national newspapers, Saatchi is seen with his hand around Lawson's throat. Saatchi accepted a police caution for assault, and the couple announced they would divorce soon afterward.
    'She was a rock'
    The two defendants, who worked for Lawson and Saatchi for a number of years, were supposed to use the cards for household expenses, but allegedly spent large amounts on themselves.
    Lawson acknowledged Wednesday she wasn't familiar with every detail of the purchases made by the Grillo sisters.
    She told the court she had employed Elisabetta, also known as Lisa, while her ex-husband had hired Francesca.
    "I loved Lisa. She came to me in a difficult time in my life. She was a rock," Lawson said.
    She said Elisabetta Grillo had left her job for a while, and when she came back she'd been increasingly bitter and unhappy.
    "I do not think her bitterness was towards me personally. I think it was towards her life," the chef said.
    Lawson ignored the crowd of reporters and photographers waiting outside Isleworth Crown Court as she entered earlier, wearing black and looking somber.
    Transactions top $1 million
    Saatchi's accountant gave details of the sisters' alleged spending on luxury goods in court last week, including purchases from Prada, Miu Miu and Louis Vuitton.
    The prosecution also showed Saatchi a list of the top 50 transactions made by the sisters, totaling more than $1 million, which he said he did not recognize and had not authorized.
    He did not know whether Lawson had approved them, he said.
    Lawson, whose culinary skills and flirtatious manner have long entranced UK audiences, has also appeared as a judge on ABC show "The Taste" in the United States. A second season of the show is due to air in January.

     

    TOP EUROPE STORIES

Boris Johnson fails live 'IQ test'


  • In first appearance since controversial speech, London mayor fails to answer two IQ questions and refuses to answer third


    In first appearance since controversial speech, London mayor fails to answer two IQ questions and refuses to answer third

    Can you beat Boris Johnson on IQ test questions?
    Link to video: Boris Johnson fails 'IQ test' on live radio
    The London mayor, Boris Johnson, has proven that a high IQ and an Eton education are of little help when someone asks the cost of a cash tube fare from Angel to London Bridge live on air.
    After struggling for a minute to answer the question on an LBC radio phone-in, Johnson also failed two questions from a quiz presented like an IQ test and refused to attempt to answer a third, saying: "No one said IQ is the only measure of ability".
    It was his first public appearance since he caused controversy by suggesting some people struggle to get on in life because of their low IQs, adding that the bigger cornflakes tended to end up at the top of the packet.
    Struggling himself in the course of the 45-minute phone-in to avoid tumbling ever further down the packet, Johnson also claimed that Marble Arch tube station had once been called Selfridges, a claim he has made twice before but is untrue. There once had been a plan to rename Bond Street but it never came to pass.
    He also revealed that in his six years as London mayor he has never met the leader of the RMT union, Bob Crow, even though the union leader represents London's bus and tube workers.
    In the first IQ question he was asked: "A man builds a house with four sides of rectangular construction each side with southern exposure. A big bear comes along. What is the colour of the bear?"
    Johnson said the bear was probably brown, before admitting that he did not have a clue. The answer is white because it must be a polar bear on the north pole.
    Next he was asked: "Take two apples from three apples and what do you have?" Johnson said: "Loads of apples." He then changed his answer to one apple. The answer the questioner wanted was two apples.
    He was then asked: "I went to bed at eight in the evening last night and I wound up my clock and set my alarm to sound for nine o'clock in the morning. How many hours sleep did I get?" But Johnson refused even to attempt an answer.
    "No one said IQ is the only measure of ability," he said, perhaps sensing that he was nestling very close to the bottom of the cornflake packet by then.
    Johnson sought to defend his speech last week that was interpreted by some as saying greed is a good motivator and needs to be encouraged.
    "There is too much inequality," he said. "My speech was actually a warning against letting inequality go unchecked." He then said that "in last 20 years there has been a widening of income between rich and the poor".
    He added: "What hacks me off is people with ability have found it very difficult to progress in the last 20 years. The key thing I said is inequality is only tolerable in our society if you look after those who are finding it tough to compete and where people have ability they are allowed to get on."
    He turned on some of his critics, including the deputy prime minister, Nick Clegg, saying "people are entitled to wilfully misconstrue what I said if they so choose".
    Labour has fiercely attacked Johnson over the issue, with the shadow education secretary, Tristram Hunt, challenging Michael Gove to denounce the "unpleasant whiff of eugenics" contained in the comments.
    In what seemed to be the longest minute ever broadcast on radio, Johnson struggled to work out the cost of a one-way cash fare from Angel, his local station, to London Bridge, his place of work. He mumbled and hummed before pronouncing £6.70 and then seemed not to know the basics of the Underground zoning system.
    He was then asked about the talent show The X Factor, saying he did not have the foggiest idea about it, and whether he knew who was in the I'm A Celebrity Get Me Out of Here jungle, answering: Nick Clegg, Vince Cable and Ann Widdecombe.
    "I have not the faintest idea and why should I?" he added.
    Johnson revealed he was considering sponsorship of tube stations, saying if Samsung wanted to change Tottenham Court Road to the company name, he was not against the idea in principle so long as the right fee was paid. The cost of changing names on the maps and leaflets would be £4m alone.
    Johnson, who was speaking on the day of the latest tube fare rises, said he was looking at ideas such as ticket offices being used as coffee shops and retail spaces.
     COPY  http://www.theguardian.com/
  • Discovery of oldest human DNA in Spanish cave sheds light on evolution


     

    Discovery of oldest human DNA in Spanish cave sheds light on evolution

    Scientists say DNA strands in thigh bone of 400,000-year-old early human can help build clearer picture of human family tree
    An artist's impression of the Sima de los Huesos early humans
    An artist's impression of the Sima de los Huesos early humans that are estimated to have lived 400,000 years ago. Photograph: Kennis & Kennis/AP
    Researchers have read strands of ancient DNA teased from the thigh bone of an early human who died 400,000 years ago in what is now northern Spain.
    The genetic material was pieced together from a clutch of cells found in bone fragments – the oldest human remains ever to yield their genetic code.
    The work deepens understanding of the genetics of human evolution by about 200,000 years, raising hopes that researchers can build a clearer picture of the earliest branches of the human family tree by studying the genetic make-up of fossilised remains dug up elsewhere.
    "This is proof of principle that it can be done," said Matthias Meyer at the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig. "We are now very eager to explore other sites of a similar age."
    The thigh bone was among the remains of at least 28 early human ancestors found at the bottom of a vertical shaft in a cave complex in the Atapuerca mountains in northern Spain. The Sima de los Huesos, or "pit of bones", lies 30 metres underground and half a kilometre from the cave system's nearest current entrance.
    Scientists managed to analyse DNA found in the thigh bone of this skeleton found in Spain Scientists managed to analyse DNA found in the thigh bone of this skeleton found in Spain. Photograph: Javier Trueba/AP The individuals at Sima de los Huesos looked a little like Neanderthals, and many anthropologists classified them as Homo heidelbergensis, a potential forerunner of modern humans. The corpses were probably washed into the pit rather than buried intentionally.
    Meyer's team sequenced DNA found in tiny sausage-shaped structures called mitochondria, which sit inside cells and provide them with power. Mitochondria are passed down the maternal line only, unlike DNA found in the cell nucleus, which carries genetic information from both parents and their ancestors.
    The age of the bone fragments meant the cells and their DNA were badly degraded. "This is the hardest sample I have ever worked on that yielded a result," said Meyer.
    Meyer's team dated the bone fragments to 400,000 years old, but further analysis left them baffled. The mitochondrial DNA did not match that of Neanderthals, but was closer to a sister group called the Denisovans that lived in Siberia. Details of the study appear in the journal Nature.
    Meyer says there are a number of explanations, but admits more work is needed. One possibility is that an older lineage of human ancestors, perhaps Homo erectus, bred with the ancestors of the Sima de la Huesos individuals, and passed on their mitochondria. But several other explanations are being explored by anthropologists."Either way, this new finding can help us start to disentangle the relationships of the various human groups known from the last 600,000 years," said Chris Stringer, head of human origins at the Natural History Museum in London. "If more mitochondrial DNA can be recovered from the Sima population of fossils, it may demonstrate how these individuals were related to each other, and how varied their population was."
    Meyer said the Leipzig group now hopes to extract so-called nuclear DNA from the Sima fossils, which contains more information but will be much harder to extract because there is far less material.
    "We have taken a first glimpse now and what we find is unexpected and confusing," he said. "But I'm confident we'll get more data, and then it's very likely we'll be able to nail down some hard facts, about whether these Sima de la Heusos guys are the ancestors of Neanderthals, the ancestors of both Neanderthals and Denisovans, or even something completely different."

     COPY  http://www.theguardian.com/

    Chancellor announces £1bn-a-year spending cuts


    • Chancellor announces £1bn-a-year spending cuts

      George Osborne
      On day before autumn statement, George Osborne tells ministers to find more efficiency savings

      George Osborne
      George Osborne is to deliver the government's autumn statement on Thursday. Photograph: Andrew Cowie/AFP/Getty Images
      The chancellor, George Osborne, and the chief secretary to the Treasury, Danny Alexander, have written to their cabinet colleagues to tell them the government will reduce central departmental spending by over a £1bn a year over the next three years (2013-14 to 2015-16).
      To lock in this lower level of spending, budget reductions of 1.1% will also be made across departments' resource budgets over the next two financial years, 2014-15 and 2015-16, delivering savings of more than £1bn each year.
      News of the reduction comes before Osborne delivers the government's autumn statement on Thursday.
      In addition to existing underspends, departments are expected to identify further efficiency savings and to continue exercising strong financial discipline across all areas of their budgets.
      Health, schools, aid, local government, HMRC and the security services will be exempt from these reductions.
      The Ministry of Defence will be given exceptional flexibility to keep its expected underspends of £800m and roll them over to next year.
      Earlier on Wednesday it emerged that the coalition is having to raid its school capital budget to find cash to build new school kitchens and fulfil its pledge to let all primary schoolchildren aged five to seven receive a free school meal, a pledge announced by Nick Clegg at his party conference in September.
      Whitehall sources said Clegg had been forced to take money from the schools maintenance budget to fund emergency construction and improvement of school kitchens. The £150m shortfall stems from higher demand for school meals.
      The need to build extra kitchens had not been foreseen at the time of the £600m announcement.
      Initial leaks had suggested the shortfall amounted to £200m, but after the overspending story initially leaked, the Lib Dems said the one-off capital allocation was in fact £150m. Of this £80m will be from the Department for Education schools maintenance budget, while another £70m will be new money coming from the Treasury.
      In an issue that was taken to the quad – the group of four most senior ministers in the coalition including Clegg, David Cameron and Osborne – the Department for Education complained that the extra money could require ministers to raid its basic needs budget, the fund used to deal with the rise in the number of primary schoolchildren caused by a baby boom.
      However, instead it was agreed that unspent money from the DfE's maintenance budget would have to be deployed.
      Cameron sided with Clegg in the quad meeting, according to coalition sources, in return for the Liberal Democrats ceding some ground on environmental issues.
      A DfE source said: "There is no spare money in either the basic needs or maintenance budget to pay for Clegg's kitchens."
      The source denied the money due to be announced in the autumn statement would be new, but said it would be taken from elsewhere in the department's budget. One Whitehall source said: "Even for Clegg, this gimmick does not work if he has to raid the budget for primary school places." Negotiations were continuing on Wednesday.

    £150m hole in school meals pledge


  • £150m hole in school meals pledge

    funding hole free school meals pledge nick clegg michael gove
    Clegg forced to raid school maintenance budget to plug shortfall - initially feared to be as high as £200m


    Revealed: £150m funding hole in free school meals pledge

    Nick Clegg is forced to raid school maintenance budget to plug shortfall – initially feared to be as high as £200m
    funding hole free school meals pledge nick clegg michael gove
    A Department for Education source said: 'There is no spare money in the budget to pay for Clegg's kitchens.' Photograph: Stefan Rousseau/PA Archive/Press Association Ima
    The coalition is having to raid its school capital budget to find cash to build new school kitchens and fulfil its pledge to let all primary schoolchildren aged five to seven receive a free school meal, a pledge announced by Nick Clegg at his party conference in September.
    Whitehall sources said Clegg had been forced to take money from the schools maintenance budget to fund emergency construction and improvement of school kitchens. The £150m shortfall stems from higher demand for school meals.
    The need to build extra kitchens had not been foreseen at the time of the £600m announcement.
    Initial leaks had suggested the shortfall amounted to £200m, but after the overspending story initially leaked, the Lib Dems said the one-off capital allocation was in fact £150m. Of this £80m will be from the Department for Education schools maintenance budget, while another £70m will be new money coming from the Treasury.
    In an issue that was taken to the quad – the group of four most senior ministers in the coalition including Clegg, David Cameron and George Osborne – the Department for Education complained that the extra money could require ministers to raid its basic needs budget, the fund used to deal with the rise in the number of primary schoolchildren caused by a baby boom.
    However, instead it was agreed that unspent money from the DfE's maintenance budget would have to be deployed.
    Cameron sided with Clegg in the Quad meeting, according to coalition sources, in return for the Liberal Democrats ceding some ground on environmental issues.
    A DfE source said: "There is no spare money in either the basic needs or maintenance budget to pay for Clegg's kitchens."
    The source denied the money due to be announced in the autumn statement would be new, but said it would be taken from elsewhere in the department's budget. One Whitehall source said: "Even for Clegg, this gimmick does not work if he has to raid the budget for primary school places." Negotiations were continuing on Wednesday.
    Clegg won the extra £600m for free school meals for the scheme to begin in September 2014 as part of last-minute autumn deal that allowed David Cameron to spend on a marriage tax allowance.
    It is thought that Michael Gove, the education secretary, regarded the free school meals proposal as political showmanship designed to win Clegg votes at the election, but unlikely to do anything substantial to improve schooling.
    There are also wider reports of increasingly tense relations between Clegg and the education secretary, with Clegg telling the cabinet secretary, Jeremy Heywood, at one point that he found it increasingly difficult to work with Gove.
    At education questions on Tuesday Gove went out of his way to praise Clegg in a bid to pour oil on troubled waters.
    The two sides are at loggerheads over the decision of Clegg, without warning, to announce that he wanted qualified teachers to work in free schools, something the Liberal Democrats had endorsed before but had never been highlighted by the deputy prime minister.
    At the outset of the coalition the two men appeared to be ideological allies.
    Part of the difficulty is that Clegg is taking an increasing interest in early-years education, partly to mark out some distinctive personal ground before the election. Clegg has been closely involved in announcements extending childcare support, the pupil premium and helping the young unemployed.
    The autumn statement is expected to include a commitment to lift employers' requirement to pay national insurance for workers aged under 21. This would cut the cost of employing young people by an average of £520 a year per worker.
    The free school meals pledge has been popular with the public, but led to some criticism within Clegg's own party.
    Nick Harvey, the former Liberal Democrat defence minister, described the announcement as "absolutely astonishing".
    He told the Huffington Post he wanted the money to be better targeted so free lunches would be given to poor children from when they started school at five to when they finished at 18.
    He said: "Someone, somewhere, has found £600m a year we didn't know about down the back of a filing cabinet and has come up with the brilliant brainwave that the best way to spend it is to give a free school meal to all five-, six- and seven-year-olds – regardless of their income level. I am sitting there, gawping in open-mouthed astonishment."
    The Liberal Democrat schools minister, David Laws, said: "Free school meals have multiple benefits – children concentrate more in school when they get a proper, healthy, lunch; they eat more healthily; pressure on household budgets is relieved; and families on low incomes who go back to work are helped too – by no longer losing all their free school meal entitlements."
  • Crisis in Syria - Jihadist Groups Gain in Turmoil Across Middle East

    Jihadist Groups Gain in Turmoil Across Middle East

    Al Qaeda’s leader, Ayman al-Zawahri, has indicated that he views Syria as a promising staging ground, and officials are concerned that a base there could present a rising threat to Israel and Europe.


    Jihadist Groups Gain in Turmoil Across Middle East

    Ahmed Jadallah/Reuters
    An Islamist fighter roamed through Aleppo, Syria, last December. Infighting among jihadist groups has recently mitigated their threat there, but that may not last.
    WASHINGTON — Intensifying sectarian and clan violence has presented new opportunities for jihadist groups across the Middle East and raised concerns among American intelligence and counterterrorism officials that militants aligned with Al Qaeda could establish a base in Syria capable of threatening Israel and Europe.

    Guillaume Briquet/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images
    Fighters with the Nusra Front on Aleppo’s outskirts in April. Al Qaeda’s leader sees Syria as a promising staging ground.

    The new signs of an energized but fragmented jihadist threat, stretching from Mali and Libya in the west to Yemen in the east, have complicated the narrative of a weakened Al Qaeda that President Obama offered in May in a landmark speech heralding the end of the war on terrorism. The leaders of the Senate and House intelligence committees, Senator Dianne Feinstein of California and Representative Mike Rogers of Michigan, raised warnings in an interview on CNN on Sunday when they said that Americans were “not safer” from terrorist attacks than they were in 2011.
    The concerns are based in part on messages relayed this year by Ayman al-Zawahri, Al Qaeda’s overall leader, indicating that he views Syria — where the number of jihadist rebels and foreign fighters is steadily rising — as a promising staging ground.
    Some analysts and American officials say the chaos there could force the Obama administration to take a more active role to stave off potential threats among the opposition groups fighting against the government of President Bashar al-Assad. But striking at jihadist groups in Syria would pose formidable political, military and legal obstacles, and could come at the cost of some kind of accommodation — even if only temporary or tactical — with Mr. Assad’s brutal but secular government, analysts say.
    “We need to start talking to the Assad regime again” about counterterrorism and other issues of shared concern, said Ryan C. Crocker, a veteran diplomat who has served in Syria, Iraq and Afghanistan. “It will have to be done very, very quietly. But bad as Assad is, he is not as bad as the jihadis who would take over in his absence.”
    It is not clear whether or when the White House would be willing to make such an abrupt shift in approach after years of supporting the Syrian opposition and calling for Mr. Assad’s ouster. It would certainly require delicate negotiations with Middle Eastern allies who were early and eager supporters of Syrian rebel groups, notably Saudi Arabia.
    One growing source of concern is the number of Muslims from Western countries who have gone to fight in Syria and might eventually return home and pose a terrorist threat. Analysts say at least 1,200 European Muslims have gone to Syria since the start of the war to join the fight, and dozens of Americans.
    Across the region, a rising tide of Islamist militancy — fueled partly by sectarian violence and partly by the collapse of Egypt’s Muslim Brotherhood in the face of opposition from the country’s military — has contributed to a recent wave of attacks, including deadly bombings in Lebanon and the Sinai Peninsula as well as the daily carnage in Syria and Iraq.
    The violence has underscored the continuing disarray across the Middle East in the wake of the 2011 Arab Spring uprisings. Above all, it is the chaos of Syria, where foreign jihadis appear to be building to a critical mass and have overwhelmed the Western strategy of support for the moderate opposition, that could drive the Obama administration toward greater involvement, analysts say.
    But it is not at all clear what form that involvement might take. American officials are unlikely to open a new front of drone strikes in Syria. Other options carry large risks. In early October, American commandos carried out raids in Libya and Somalia aimed at capturing terrorist suspects. The Libya raid was successful; the one in Somalia was not.
    To some extent, infighting among the jihadist groups in Syria has recently mitigated the threat there, but it is not clear how long that will last. Mr. Zawahri sent an envoy, Abu Khalid al-Suri, in an effort to resolve disputes between the two main factions, the Nusra Front and the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria.
    “To the extent that I am concerned about Al Qaeda the brand, it’s that it is clearly expanding its affiliates, both in number and in some cases in capability,” Gen. Martin E. Dempsey, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, said in an interview. “We’ve got to watch and determine which ones are local, which ones are regional, and which ones are global, and each requires a different approach.”
    Those agendas can easily overlap and change, and one place where that appears to be happening is Yemen, the home to Al Qaeda’s most organized and threatening affiliate. A series of clashes in the past month between Zaydi Muslim militia fighters and hard-line Sunnis in Yemen’s remote northwest has led to calls for a wider religious war, and there are reports of training camps being established for that purpose, Yemeni officials say. 
      In Yemen, as in Syria, this sectarian dynamic may appear to divert the militants’ attention away from the West. But the accompanying radicalization and militancy creates “the perfect environment for Al Qaeda” in a country where the terrorist group already has a strong foothold, said one Yemeni official.
    Multimedia
    Even as an American drone campaign continues to kill people suspected as militants in Yemen, the Qaeda affiliate based there gained at least $20 million in ransom payments earlier this year from the governments of Qatar and Oman, which paid to free two groups of European hostages, according to American and Yemeni officials. That is enough to fuel their operations for years, the officials said.
    A string of recent deadly attacks on Yemeni military targets has also made clear that Al Qaeda “has infiltrated our security services” to a greater extent, the Yemeni official said. In one of those attacks, a band of six jihadists disguised in army uniforms commandeered a military post with dozens of soldiers inside and held it for three days, repelling repeated efforts to free the men.
    In addition to the rising number and deadliness of attacks, there are signs of possible cross-pollination among some of the jihadist groups around the region. American officials say that the Yemen-based Al Qaeda affiliate, Al Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula, has regular contact with jihadist groups in Lebanon and in the Sinai Peninsula, where there have been near-daily attacks since the Egyptian military ousted the Islamist president Mohamed Morsi in July.
    Despite extensive Egyptian military efforts to confront them, the Sinai militant groups remain strong and have powerful new weapons — including surface-to-air missiles that could take down airliners — obtained from Libya after its civil war, said Ehud Yaari, an Israel-based security analyst for the Washington Institute for Near East Policy.
    The disarray in Libya, where the weak transitional government is largely hostile to the nation’s fractious militias, is also a source of increasing concern. Terrorism analysts say southern Libya has become a safe haven for a range of jihadists. “All of our regional partners are very afraid of the instability they see emanating from southern Libya,” said Maj. Gen. Patrick J. Donahue II, the commander of American Army forces assigned to Africa.
    Other extremist groups are redoubling their efforts across Africa. Last month the State Department branded Boko Haram, the homegrown Islamist insurgent movement in Nigeria, as a foreign terrorist group. Its attacks have left thousands dead in a decade.
    “Whether they are dismayed by the way things played out in Egypt or by the growth of Al Qaeda in Syria, the worm has turned in the Middle East in the minds of American foreign policy makers,” said William McCants, an expert on jihadist movements and a former senior adviser at the State Department. “It seems we are back to counterterrorism as a guiding focus for American policy.”

    COPY  http://www.nytimes.com/

    Ukrainian President Monitors Unrest at Home on Visit to China

    Ukrainian President Monitors Unrest at Home on Visit to China

    Though the government is largely ignoring protesters’ demands, it has said the police are barred from the use of force against peaceful protesters.
    • In Kiev City Hall, Energized Protesters Settle In for a Long Winter’s Uprising

      Ukrainian President Monitors Unrest at Home on Visit to China

      Sergey Ponomarev for The New York Times
      Antigovernment protesters in Independence Square on Wednesday in Kiev.
      KIEV, Ukraine — The bulletins started arriving from President Viktor F. Yanukovich’s press service at 6 a.m. Ukraine time on Wednesday — not with updates about the besieged public buildings or the occupation of Independence Square by thousands of protesters here — but with news of his visit to the Museum of Qin Terra Cotta Warriors and Horses in Xi’an, China.
      As widespread civic unrest continued for a fourth day by demonstrators clamoring for his resignation, Mr. Yanukovich proceeded with a long-planned state visit. He saw the ancient collection of artifacts, met with the government chairman in Shaanxi Province, toured a factory of the Chinese Aviation Industrial Corporation and flew on to Beijing for a business conference.
      In Kiev, the interior minister, Vitaly Zakharchenko, whom many here hold responsible for a violent and bloody crackdown on protesters by riot police early Saturday morning, issued a statement saying that he had given orders to police banning “the use force against participants of peaceful gatherings that are taking place in the capital of Ukraine and other cities.”
      With Mr. Yanukovich largely ignoring the protesters’ demands and the police standing down, protesters encamped ever more deeply in Kiev City Hall and at least two other public buildings, and all throughout Independence Square. It seemed clear that the civic action that some are calling the “Euro Revolution” seemed to be shaping up as a contest of stamina and patience.
      “It’s a war of attrition,” said Yuri Levchenko, an official with the nationalist Svoboda Party. “Whoever gives up first,” he said, “loses.”
      There were increasing signs that Mr. Yanukovich’s decision not to sign political and free trade accords with the European Union, under pressure from Russia, had put him in a politically untenable situation. It has undoubtedly raised sharp risks for his country, which faces a severe economic crisis and is in desperate need of a financial package of $17 billion or more.
      Ukrainian officials had been in discussions with the International Monetary Fund over an aid package, but ultimately said they were unwilling to carry out the painful austerity measures and other changes that had been set as a condition for help.
      At some point, they may have no choice. The Ukrainian Central Bank was forced to intervene in currency markets on Wednesday to prop up the hryvnia.
      Meanwhile, Ukrainian officials have been looking to Russia and China as alternate sources of financing. Both countries have helped Ukraine in the past, but as the financial situation worsens it is not clear that additional assistance will be forthcoming.
      A deputy prime minister of Ukraine, Yuri Boiko, traveled on Wednesday to Moscow, where he met with Prime Minister Dmitri A. Medvedev and a deputy prime minister, Igor Shuvalov. Russia has shown no tolerance for the sort of civil disobedience playing out in Kiev and Mr. Medvedev warned Mr. Boiko of the Kremlin’s aversion to instability.
      “You are having quite an active political season now,” Mr. Medvedev said, according to the Interfax news service. “Certainly, we are closely following what is going on in your country, but, undeniably, this is Ukraine’s internal affair. Although, certainly, it is very important to maintain stability and order in the country.”
      Western leaders, in recent days, have issued their own demands, warning Ukraine that relations would suffer badly if there were a repeat of the bloodshed Saturday when riot police violently dispersed some protesters.
      The statement by Mr. Zakharchenko, promising no further use of force, came amid intensified international criticism, from Western governments and human rights groups, over Saturday’s events, and as Kiev prepared to welcome a large group of foreign ministers for a meeting of the ministerial council of the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe.
      Even before the outbreak of unrest, Secretary of State John Kerry had announced that he was canceling his plans to attend the conference, in part to send a signal over Mr. Yanukovich’s last-minute decision to back away from far-reaching political and free trade agreements with the European Union. Mr. Kerry went instead to Moldova, which has signed a preliminary version of the accords.
      The German foreign minister, Guido Westerwelle, arrived in Kiev on Wednesday and met with opposition leaders in Independence Square, where they have established a tent city and a stage featuring virtually round-the-clock parade of speeches or musical performances.
      “It is clear that Ukraine is in the midst of huge internal discussions,” Mr. Westerwelle said in a statement released by the German government. “Here Europe must be active, because it is about Europe.”
      Meanwhile in Kiev, demonstrators continued to occupy City Hall and the Trade Unions building, and had also take over the International Center for Culture and Art, where hundreds of protesters were sleeping on the corridor floors and volunteers were serving sandwiches of smoked fish.
      Demonstrators continued to surround the nearby Cabinet Ministry building in a bid to paralyze the government and also sought to block the entrances of the Central Bank next door. 
      COPY  http://www.nytimes.com/

    Postagem em destaque

    Ao Planalto, deputados criticam proposta de Guedes e veem drible no teto com mudança no Fundeb Governo quer que parte do aumento na participação da União no Fundeb seja destinada à transferência direta de renda para famílias pobres

    Para ajudar a educação, Políticos e quem recebe salários altos irão doar 30% do soldo que recebem mensalmente, até o Governo Federal ter f...